Recipe Playbook: 25 Best Moonshine Flavors and Recipes for Fall and Football

Fall and football—two American traditions that belong together. Whether you’re tailgating at the stadium or hosting a watch party, nothing completes the experience like a great cocktail. With Midnight Moon’s bold, all-natural flavors and a 100% corn base, our ‘shine elevates every game day gathering. We’ve got flavors to match every season, and this fall, we’re sharing our top picks and 25 best moonshine recipes. Sure, Apple Pie Moonshine is a classic favorite, but we’ve got a few surprises in store, like pumpkin-flavored cocktails, coffee flavors, and more.

Here’s your ultimate playbook of the 25 best moonshine recipes and flavors to make your fall and football festivities unforgettable.

Best Moonshine Flavors for Fall

As the leaves turn and football season kicks off, it’s time to upgrade your tailgates and watch parties with some truly unforgettable moonshine cocktails. Midnight Moon’s bold flavors and smooth finish make it the perfect spirit for crafting fall-inspired drinks that will keep the party going well into overtime. From the classic punch of our 100 Proof Moonshine to indulgent favorites like Peanut Butter and Apple Pie Moonshakes, this playbook is your go-to guide for must-try recipes that perfectly capture the spirit of fall and football.

Here are our top 5 fall moonshine flavors:

1. 
   Apple Pie Moonshine

   Perfect for: Bobbing for apples, cozy nights by the fire.
   Our quintessential fall favorite, Apple Pie Moonshine, is crafted with real apple juice and a blend of cinnamon. It’s like a slice of Grandma’s famous apple pie in liquid form.

   More about Apple Pie Moonshine
   
   
   

2. 
   Dill Pickle Moonshine

   Perfect for: Tailgating, game-day snacks.
   Dill Pickle Moonshine adds a zesty punch to your game-day beers. Its tangy excitement is a rollercoaster for your taste buds.

   More about Dill Pickle Moonshine
   
   
   

3. 
   Cherry Moonshine
   

   Perfect for: Adding a fruity twist and boozy snack to your sip.
   Bursting with the perfect balance of sweetness and tartness, Cherry Moonshine is like a trip to the orchard in every sip.

   More about Cherry Moonshine
   
   
   

4. 
   Peanut Butter Moonshine

   Perfect for: Tailgate cocktails, autumn bonfires, and dessert drinks.
   Smooth and nutty, Peanut Butter Moonshine is a cozy fall treat straight from the jar.

   More about Peanut Butter Moonshine
   
   

5. 
   Midnight Moon 100 Proof Moonshine

   Perfect for: Any occasion, versatile mixing.
   Our 100 Proof Moonshine is distilled three times from American corn, offering a crisp flavor with an undeniable kick.

   More about 100 Proof Moonshine
   
   

Honorary Mention: Apple Pie Moonshake

Perfect for: Dessert cocktails, sweet treats.
Apple Pie Moonshake combines the indulgence of milkshakes with the warmth of Apple Pie Moonshine, making it an autumn delight.

More about Apple Pie Moonshake

 

Crowd-Pleasing Moonshine Recipes for Fall

Welcome to Midnight Moon Fall Cocktail Recipe Playbook! When it comes to incorporating your favorite fall flavors into moonshine recipes, we have you covered. Whether you’re hosting a Halloween party, a football tailgate or a bonfire, we’ve perfected tons of moonshine cocktails for you and your friends to enjoy. Find your go-to fall flavor and let the ‘shine sipping begin! Click the cocktail recipe name to jump to recipe.

1. 1. 1. 1. Apple Pie Moonshine Mule
      2. 2. Apple Pie Hot Toddy
      3. 3. Caramel Apple Cider Spritzer
      4. 4. Pumpkin Apple Shandy
      5. 5. Full Moon Punch
      6. 6. Spiked Pumpkin Spice Latte
      7. 7. Apple Ginger Ale
      8. 8. Apple Pie Chai
      9. 9. Apple Pie Ice Coffee
      10. 10. Peanut Butter Espresso Martini
      11. 11. Classic PB&J Shot
      12. 12. PB & Banana Sandwich
      13. 13. Peanut Butter Irish Coffee
      14. 14. Peanut Butter Sour
      15. 15. Peanut Butta Cookie
      16. 16. Moonshine Party Punch
      17. 17. Pumpkin Spice Espresso Martini
      18. 18. Pumpkin Pie Moscow Mule
      19. 19. Pumpkin Spice White Russian
      20. 20. Creamy Caramel Apple Cider
      21. 21. Cherry Cola
      22. 22. Cherry Sangria
      23. 23. Cherry Bomb
      24. 24. Dill Pickle Bloody Mary
      25. 25. Pickle Back

 

Apple Pie Moonshine Recipes

Apple Pie Moonshine Mule: The Fan Favorite

This crisp and refreshing twist on the classic Moscow Mule brings fall flavors front and center with Midnight Moon Apple Pie. Perfect for crisp autumn days.

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 2 oz Midnight Moon Apple Pie
      • 4 oz ginger beer
      • Splash of lemon juice
      • Cinnamon stick.
        
        

Pour apple pie moonshine over ice, top with ginger beer, and garnish with a cinnamon stick.

 

Hot Toddy: Game Day Warmer

As the temperatures drop, this apple pie moonshine hot toddy is the perfect drink to warm you up and keep the tailgate going strong.

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 2 oz Midnight Moon Apple Pie Moonshine
      • 4 oz hot apple cider
      • Cinnamon stick for garnish.
        
        

Combine apple pie moonshine and cider in a mug, stir, and garnish with cinnamon

 

Caramel Apple Cider Spritzer

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 2 oz Midnight Moon Apple Pie Moonshine
      • 4 oz apple cider (chilled)
      • 1 oz caramel syrup
      • 2 oz club soda (or sparkling water)
      • Apple Slices and cinnamon stick for garnish
        
        

In a cocktail shaker, combine the Apple Pie Moonshine, apple cider, and caramel syrup. Shake well to blend the flavors. Fill a glass with ice and strain the mixture into glass. Top off with club soda to add a refreshing fizz, then stir gently. Garnish with fresh apple slices and a cinnamon stick for extra flavor. 

 

Pumpkin Apple Shandy

Ingredients:

1. 1. • • 2 oz. Midnight Moon Apple Pie
        • 2 oz. Pumpkin Beer
        • ¼ Cup Orange Juice
          
          

Combine pumpkin beer, Midnight Moon Apple Pie moonshine and orange juice. Pour into glass and garnish with an apple slice.

 

Full Moon Punch

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 1 jar Midnight Moon Apple Pie Moonshine
      • 64 oz. spiced apple cider
      • ½ cup cinnamon-honey syrup
      • ¼ cup lemon juice
      • 6 cups ginger beer
      • Apple slices and lemon slices, for garnish
      • Ice, for serving

For the cinnamon-honey syrup: 1 cup honey, 1 cup water, 4-5 cinnamon sticks. 

Combine honey and water in a small pot and bring to a gentle simmer. Once a foam starts to form at the surface, remove from heat and add cinnamon sticks. Let steep for 1 hour before straining into an air-tight container or squeeze bottle. Then combine Moonshine, cider, cinnamon-honey syrup, lemon juice, and ginger beer in a large punch bowl and stir. Garnish bowl with apples and lemon slices, and ladle punch over ice to serve.

 

Spiked Pumpkin Spice Latte

Ingredients: 

1. 1. • 1 oz. Midnight Moon Apple Pie Moonshine
      • ⅛ Cup Heavy Cream
      • ⅛ Cup Whole Milk
      • ½ Tbsp Pumpkin Spice
      • ½ Tbsp Vanilla Extract
      • 1½ Tbsp Pumpkin Puree
      • ½ Cup Strong Coffee
      • 1 oz. Apple Pie Moonshake Cream Liqueur
      • Optional: Whipped Cream
        
        

Brew coffee. Microwave or heat milk and cream on a stovetop (but do not boil). Add pumpkin spice, steep for 10 minutes, strain and reheat until milk mixture is hot. Whisk in vanilla and pumpkin puree. Stir in coffee and alcohol. Sprinkle with pumpkin spice and add whipped cream.

 

Apple Ginger Ale

Ingredients: 

1. 1. • 2 oz. Midnight Moon Apple Pie Moonshine
      • 4 oz. Ginger ale
        
        

Mix apple pie moonshine and ginger ale together in a glass with ice. Tailgate responsibly!

 

Apple Pie Chai Tea

Ingredients: 

1. 1. • 1.5 oz. Midnight Moon Apple Pie Moonshake Cream Liqueur
      • 0.5 oz. Midnight Moon Apple Pie Moonshine
      • 6 oz. Chai tea
        
        

Prepare your hot Chai tea, then add moonshine and Moonshake. Garnish with cinnamon stick. Ding! Order up.

 

Apple Pie Ice Coffee

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 2 oz. Apple Pie Moonshake Cream Liqueur
      • 4 oz.  Coffee
      • Ice
        
        

Combine ingredients over ice, stir and enjoy! 

 

 

Peanut Butter Moonshine Recipes

Peanut Butter Espresso Martini: Halftime Pick-Me-Up

Boost your halftime break with this delicious martini! It combines rich Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine with a shot of espresso for a tasty treat. This popular cocktail is the perfect mix of creamy sweetness and caffeine to keep you going through the second half.

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 2 oz Peanut Butter Moonshine
      • 1 oz coffee liqueur
      • Shot of espresso
        
        

Shake peanut butter moonshine and coffee liqueur with ice, strain into a chilled glass, and garnish with chocolate shavings.

 

Classic PB&J Shooter

The flavors of childhood get a grown-up twist with this fun shooter, combining peanut butter and raspberry moonshine for a nostalgic kick. If looking for a lighter option, swap the raspberry ‘shine for cranberry juice. Pro tip: they make for awesome jello shots. 

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 1.5 oz Peanut Butter Moonshine
      • 1.5 oz Raspberry Moonshine
        
        

Shake with ice, strain into shot glasses.

 

Peanut Butter and Banana Sandwich Cocktail: Fun and Flavorful 

Bring the comfort of your favorite sandwich into a glass with this playful cocktail. The creamy peanut butter and sweet banana liqueur create an irresistible combination.

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 2 oz Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine
      • 1 oz banana liqueur
      • Banana slice with peanut butter for garnish
        
        

Shake with ice and garnish with the peanut butter banana slice.

 

Peanut Butter Irish Coffee

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 2 oz. Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine
      • 4 oz. Coffee (hot)
      • Whipped cream
        
        

Combine ingredients and top with whipped cream. 

 

Peanut Butter Sour

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 3 oz. Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine
      • 1 oz. Lemon juice
      • 0.5 oz Lime juice
      • 1 oz. Simple syrup
      • Egg white
        
        

Shake it like a polaroid picture then pour it up or on the rocks. 

 

Peanut Butta Cookie

Ingredients:

• 1 oz. Peanut Butter Moonshine
• 2 oz. Cookies & Cream Moonshake Liqueur
• Reese’s Cup (to garnish)

 

 

 

80/100 Proof Moonshine Recipes

Midnight Moon Party Punch: Tailgate Crowd-Pleaser

Hosting a large tailgate? This punch, featuring a mix of Midnight Moon’s best flavors, is ideal for keeping your guests refreshed and ready to cheer all day.

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 2 cups Midnight Moon 100 Proof
      • 2 cups Lemonade Moonshine
      • 4 cups cranberry juice
      • 2 cups pineapple juice
      • 1 cup orange juice
      • Ginger ale
        
        

Combine in a large punch bowl, add ice, and garnish with fruit slices.

 

Pumpkin Spice Espresso Martini

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 1 oz. Midnight Moon Original Moonshine
      • 1 oz. Apple Pie Moonshake
      • 1 oz. Espresso
      • 0.5 oz. Pumpkin Spice Syrup
        
        

Combine Moonshake, Midnight Moon Moonshine and cream into glass over ice. Shake lightly until combined and cold. Strain into a chilled cocktail glass and enjoy! 

 

Pumpkin Pie Moscow Mule

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 1½ oz. Midnight Moon Original
      • 1 Tbsp Pumpkin Butter
      •  ½ Lime (juiced)
      • 4 oz. Ginger Beer
      • Cinnamon Stick
        
        

Combine Midnight Moon Original, pumpkin butter and lime juice in a shaker with ice. Shake and strain over glass with ice. Top with ginger beer and garnish with cinnamon stick.

 

Pumpkin Spice White Russian

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 1.5 oz. Midnight Moon Original 80 Proof
      • 1.5 oz. Pumpkin spice creamer
      • 1 oz. Midnight Moon Apple Pie Moonshake Cream Liqueur
      • Whipped cream (optional)
        
        

Combine Moonshake, Midnight Moon Moonshine and cream into glass over ice. Shake lightly until combined and cold. Pour into glasses and top with whipped cream and pumpkin pie spice. 

 

Creamy Caramel Apple Cider

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 1 oz. Original 80 Proof Moonshine
      • 1.5 oz. Apple Pie Moonshake
      • 4 oz. Apple cider
      • Caramel sauce
      • Cinnamon sugar
        
        

Combine ingredients in a cocktail shaker with ice. Shake and serve. 

 

 

Cherry Moonshine Recipes

 

Cherry Cola: The Tailgate Essential

This delightful combination of Midnight Moon Cherry Moonshine and cola is a game day essential. Easy to make and always a hit, Cherry Cola cocktail recipe is the perfect drink for when you’re short on time but need a easy recipe.

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 2 oz Cherry Moonshine
      • Regular or diet cola
      • Moonshine cherries

Pour ingredients in a glass over ice. Top with 1-2 moonshine cherries for a snack with your sip!

Cherry Moonshine Sangria

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 2 oz Cherry Moonshine
      • 0.5 oz. Triple Sec
      • 0.25 oz. Fresh lemon juice
      • 4 oz. Sauvignon blanc white wine
      • Moonshine cherreis
        
        

Cherry Bomb

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 2 oz. Midnight Moon Cherry Moonshine
      • 3 oz. Red Bull or preferred energy drink
      • 0.5 oz. Simple syrup
        
        

Mix together and throw it back!

 

 

Dill Pickle Moonshine Recipes

 

Dill Pickle Bloody Mary: The Bold Starter

Swap vodka for Midnight Moon Dill Pickle Moonshine for a savory twist on the classic Bloody Mary. This game day drink packs a punch with bold flavors and makes for the perfect brunch-time cocktail.

Ingredients:

1. 1. • 1.5 oz Dill Pickle Moonshine
      • 1.5 oz Midnight Moon 100 Proof
      • 4 oz tomato juice
      • Hot sauce of choice (as many dashes as you like!)
      • Worcestershire
      • Moonshine pickles
      • Celery stick
        
        

Combine Midnight Moon Dill Pickle with hot sauce, Worcestershire, tomato juice, salt and pepper. Pour Bloody Mary mixture over the ice and garnish with pickle, olive and bacon.

 

Pickle Back

Ingredients: 

1. 1. • 1 oz. Midnight Moon Dill Pickle
      • 1 oz. Midnight Moon American Whiskey
        
        

Place Dill Pickle Moonshine is first shot glass and whiskey in second shot glass. Enjoy a shot of whiskey followed by the Midnight Moon Dill Pickle.

 

No matter where your taste buds take you this fall, Midnight Moon moonshine has you covered with every fall flavor and recipe you need to have a good time. Head over to our online store to pick up a few mason jars of our fall moonshine flavors before your next event!