Ultimate Guide to Crafting Peanut Butter Cocktails

Craving a cocktail that’s as creamy and irresistible as your favorite peanut butter treat? Now that you’ve learned about the difference between peanut butter whiskey and moonshine, let’s dive into our favorite ways to infuse that roasted nutty goodness into unforgettable recipes. 

From smooth espresso martinis to divine desserts, this guide will cover everything you need to know to turn our nutty moonshine into your new favorite cocktail ingredient. Just click below to jump to a recipe!

Peanut Butter Moonshine Recipes

 

Classic Peanut Butter Cocktail Recipes 

• 1.) PB Old Fashioned
• 2.) Peanut Butter Espresso Martini
• 3.) Peanut Butter Blackberry Bramble 
•  

Fast & Easy Peanut

1. 4.) Classic Peanut Butter and Jelly 
2. 5.) PB & Coke
3. 6.) Peanut-Berry Seltzer
4. 7.) Chocolate Peanut Butter Stout 
5.  

Sweet Peanut Butter Cocktails

1. 8.) PB & J Jello Shots
2. 9.) Peanut Butter and Banana Sandwich 
3. 10.) P’nut Butta Cookie 
4.  

Beyond the Bar – Cooking with Peanut Butter Flavored Moonshine  

1. 11.) Boozy Peanut Butter Banana Pudding 
2. 12.) Spiked Apples and Peanut Butter 
3. 13.) Peanut Butter Bundt Cake 
4.  

 

Classic Peanut Butter Moonshine Recipes

 

 

1.) PB Old Fashioned  

Ingredients 

• • 2 oz. Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine 
• • 1 Dash Bitters
• • Orange slice & Cherry garnish
•  

Directions
Stir ingredients with ice until chilled. Serve over ice. Add garnish.

 

2.) Peanut Butter Espresso Martini 

Ingredients 

• • 2 oz. Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine
• • 1 oz. Coffee liqueur
• • 1 shot of espresso
•  

Directions

Shake all ingredients until chilled. Strain into a martini glass.

3.) Peanut Butter Blackberry Bramble  

Ingredients 

• • 1.5 oz. Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine 
• • 1 oz. Midnight Moon Blackberry Moonshine
• • 0.5 oz. simple syrup 
• • 1/4 cup fresh blackberries
• • soda
•  

Directions

Muddle blackberries in cocktail shaker. Add both moonshine flavors, syrup, and ice. Shake until chilled. Pour over ice, top with soda.

 

 

Fast & Easy Peanut Butter Cocktail Recipes

4.) Classic Peanut Butter and Jelly  

Ingredients 

• • 2 oz. Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine
• • 1 oz. Midnight Moon Raspberry Moonshine
•  

Directions

Shake the moonshines together until chilled. Serve as a shot or over rocks.

 

 

5.) PB & Coke   

Ingredients 

• • 2 oz. Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine
• • Cola
•  

Directions

Combine moonshine and cola into a glass with ice.

6.) Peanut-Berry Seltzer    

Ingredients 

• • 2 oz. Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine
• • 1 can berry seltzer
•  

Directions

Mix the moonshine with a berry seltzer of your choosing.

7.) Chocolate Peanut Butter Stout   

Ingredients 

• • 2 oz. Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine
• • 1 can or bottle of chocolate stout
•  

Directions

Pour your favorite chocolate stout into a pint glass. Add the shot of shine.

Sweet Peanut Butter Cocktails

8.) PB & J Jello Shots

Ingredients 

• • 1.5 cup Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine
• • 1 cup boiling water
• • 1 (3.9 oz.) box Grape-flavored gelatin (Jello®)
• • ½ cup cold water
• • 12 (2 oz.) Mini plastic jello shot cups (also known as ramekins or condiment cups)
•  

Directions

Dissolve grape jello in boiling water. Mix in cold water and moonshine. Pour the mixture into plastic cups. Chill for 3 hours. 

9.)Peanut Butter and Banana Sandwich  

Ingredients 

• • 2 oz. Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine
• • 1 oz Banana Liqueur 
•  

Directions

Pour moonshine & banana liqueur over ice.

 

10.) P’Nut Butta Cookie

Ingredients 

• • 1 oz. Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine
• • 2 oz. Midnight Moon Cookies & Cream Moonshake
• •  Mini peanut butter cup for garnish (optional)
•  

Directions

Shake ingredients with ice until chilled. Serve over ice. Add garnish.

Beyond the Bar – Cooking with Peanut Butter Flavored Moonshine

 

11.) Boozy Peanut Butter Banana Pudding 

Ingredients: Midnight Moon’s Peanut Butter flavored moonshine, vanilla pudding mix, milk, Cool Whip, bananas and Nilla wafers. Check out the full recipe. 

 

12.) Spiked Apples and Peanut Butter  

Ingredients: Peanut Butter Moonshine, apples, caramel, peanut butter, chocolate chips, crushed graham crackers, coconut shavings. Check out the full recipe.

 

12.) Peanut Butter Bundt Cake  

Ingredients: Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine, water, peanuts, yellow cake mix, vanilla pudding mix, vegetable oil, eggs, salted butter, and sugar. Check out step-by-step instructions for this recipe.

 

Perfect Occasions for Peanut Butter Moonshine Recipes

–Tailgating and BBQs 

Its bold flavor pairs well with BBQ, burgers, and other game-day staples. Add it to beer, cider or seltzer to give backyard favorites a new twist.

–Celebrations 

Bake it, shake it or shoot it…from birthdays to house-warmings bring this comforting flavor to whatever you are celebrating.

 

 

With Midnight Moon’s Peanut Butter Moonshine, the possibilities are endless. Ready to try these cocktails for yourself? Crack open a jar, mix up your favorite recipe, and let the good times flow! Order online or find a store near you today.

 

Buy Now: Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Moonshine – Free Shipping on Spirit Orders of $100 or more!