10 Valentine’s Day Moonshine Cocktails Better Than Boxed Chocolates

Let’s be honest: Valentine’s Day can feel like a high-stakes performance. Between impossible dinner reservations and overpriced menus, the “romance” can get lost in the shuffle. At Midnight Moon, we believe the best memories are made right at home.

Whether you’re looking for homemade moonshine recipes for a cozy night for two or hosting a Galentine’s bash, the secret is a spirit that tastes like a celebration. You don’t need a degree in mixology to master these moonshine mixed drinks. By using a blend of our award-winning moonshine and indulgent moonshine cream liqueurs (our signature Moonshakes), you can create professional-grade cocktails with zero stress.

The Ultimate Moonshine Cocktail Guide for Valentine’s Day

Searching for the best moonshine recipes to make your heart skip a beat? We’ve curated ten creations that highlight the versatility of moonshine—ranging from rich dessert cocktails to bright, bubbly toasts.

 

Indulgent Chocolate Moonshine Cocktails

Valentine’s Day without chocolate is like a campfire without marshmallows—technically possible, but something is definitely missing. These chocolate moonshine cocktails act as dessert and a nightcap all rolled into one.

 

#1. The Midnight Chocolate Martini

Forget the box of chocolates—drink them instead. This recipe uses our creamy chocolate brownie moonshine for a rich, velvety texture that feels like a total indulgence.

Ingredients

• 2 oz. Midnight Moon Chocolate Brownie Moonshake
• 1 oz.Midnight Moon 100 Proof Moonshine
• 0.5 oz. Heavy cream

 

To Make: Shake both moonshines with ice until frosty. Strain into a martini glass and dust with cocoa powder.

 

#2. Chocolate Covered Cherry Kiss

​​A liquid love letter to the classic confection. This moonshine cream recipe is one of our favorites.

Ingredients

• 3 oz. Midnight Moon Chocolate Brownie Moonshake
• 1 oz. Milk or heavy cream
• 1 oz. Cherry grenadine
  

 

To Make: Rim a chilled coupe or martini glass with red sanding sugar. Add all ingredients to a shaker filled with ice. Shake well until frosty, then strain into your prepared glass. Garnish with a sweet maraschino cherry.

 

#3. Chocolate Peanut Butter Strawberry Dream

This creamy moonshine dessert drink is a must-try if you enjoy nostalgic recipes.

Ingredients

• 1.5 oz. Midnight Moon Peanut Butter Cup Moonshake
• 1.5 oz. Midnight Moon Strawberry Moonshine
• 1 oz. Milk or creamer

 

To Make: Add all ingredients to a shaker with ice. Shake until cold and creamy. Strain into a chilled glass.

 

Sweet Moonshine Mixed Drinks for Two

Moonshine recipes that are sweet, sippable, and perfect for sharing with your sweetheart. Simply double the ingredients for Cupid’s cocktails below and toast!

 

#4. Strawberry Moonshine Milkshake

Throw it back to soda shop dates, but give it a grown-up kick. This blend is creamy and dreamy, best served with two straws.

Ingredients

• 1 oz. Midnight Moon Strawberry Moonshine
• 2 oz. Midnight Moon Vanilla Moonshake
• 1 cup Vanilla ice cream
• Splash of milk

 

To Make: Blend ice cream, strawberry moonshine, and moonshine cream liqueur until smooth. Serve in a tall glass topped with whipped cream and heart-shaped candies.

 

 

#5. Cupid’s Arrow Shooters

Ready to shake up a little love? These dessert shooters are sweet, potent, and the perfect way to kick off the night.

Ingredients

• 2 oz. Midnight Moon Vanilla Moonshake
• 1 oz. Amaretto
• Splash of cherry grenadine
• Red sanding sugar & whipped cream (for garnish)
  

 

To Make: Combine all ingredients in a cocktail shaker with ice. Shake it, strain it into shot glasses rimmed with red sugar, and top with whipped cream.

 

#6. Raspberry Cheesecake Shots

All the flavor of your favorite slice of cake, none of the baking required.

Ingredients

• 1.5 oz. Midnight Moon Raspberry Moonshine
• 1.5 oz. Midnight Moon Vanilla Moonshake

 

To Make: Add ingredients to a shaker filled with ice. Shake until well-chilled and serve in a shot glass rimmed with graham cracker crumbs.

 

#7. Vanilla Rose Dream Shots

Flirty, creamy, and made for two. The floral notes of rose syrup elevate the vanilla cream, making the sip feel fancy yet surprisingly easy to make.

Ingredients

• 2 oz. Midnight Moon Vanilla Moonshake
• 1 oz. Milk or heavy cream
• 0.5 oz. Rose-flavored simple syrup

 

To Make: Rim shot glasses with pink sanding sugar. Add moonshine cream, milk and simple syrup into a mixing glass. Shake ingredients with ice, strain into two shots, and toast to romance.

 

Bubbly Moonshine Mixed Drinks

For those who prefer a “light and bright” profile, these moonshine fruit recipes offer a crisp alternative to heavy creams.

 

#8. Berry Bubbly Love

Sometimes, simple is best. This crisp cocktail uses sparkling juice to give our Strawberry Moonshine a celebratory lift.

Ingredients

• 1 oz. Midnight Moon Strawberry Moonshine
• 3 oz. Sparkling grape juice or wine

 

To Make: Pour the moonshine into a champagne flute. Top with chilled sparkling beverage. Garnish with a few moonshine-infused raspberries. 

 

#9. Dirty Shirley

All grown up and ready for a good time. This moonshine recipe is a playful, nostalgic twist on the classic Shirley Temple.

Ingredients

• 2 oz. Midnight Moon Cherry Moonshine
• 4 oz. Lemon-lime soda
• Splash of grenadine
• Cherries to garnish

 

To Make: Fill a glass with ice, add cherry moonshine and soda, and finish with grenadine for that signature pink swirl. Top with a moonshine cherry and a lemon slice

 

#10 Raspberry Limoncello Spritz

Zesty, sweet, and incredibly refreshing. This moonshine cocktail is pure sunshine in a glass—ideal for slow sips on the porch as you enjoy the sunset together.

Instructions

• 1 oz. Midnight Moon Raspberry Moonshine
• 1.5 oz. Limoncello
• 0.5 oz. Simple syrup
• 2 oz. Club soda

 

To Make: Combine moonshine, limoncello, and syrup in a glass with ice. Top with club soda and stir gently.

 

Common Questions About Valentine’s Moonshine Cocktails

Q: Can I make these moonshine mixed drinks and moonshine cream cocktails ahead of time?

• • Absolutely. The moonshine cream liqueur cocktails (like the Chocolate Martini) can be pre-mixed in a pitcher and kept in the fridge. Just wait to add ice until you’re ready to serve so you don’t water down the flavor.

 

Q: What can I mix with moonshine and moonshine cream liqueurs? 

• • Moonshine is incredibly versatile. Traditional moonshine pairs well with fruit juices, club soda, and citrus-forward mixers, while moonshine cream liqueurs (Moonshakes) shine when mixed with milk, ice cream, coffee, or dessert liqueurs like amaretto and limoncello. As for serving, classic glassware works beautifully—but we’re partial to the ol’ mason jar.

 

Q: Can I use moonshine in baking?

• • Yes! Many moonshine recipes aren’t just for drinking. You can add a splash of Apple Pie Moonshine to a glaze or Vanilla Moonshake to a cake batter for an extra layer of flavor. They’re also great for no-bake desserts, like using our Cookies & Cream Moonshake to make a delicious no-bake cheesecake.

 

Q: What kind of glassware should I use?

• • While a martini glass is classic, we’re partial to the ol’jar. Serving moonshine mixed drinks in small mason jars fits the Midnight Moon vibe perfectly—relaxed, authentic, and ready for a good time.

Q: Where can I buy Midnight Moon’s flavored moonshine and Moonshakes?

• • You can find Midnight Moon’s full lineup of fruit-infused moonshine and moonshine creams at major liquor retailers. Use our Store Locator to find a jar near you, or order online and get our best moonshine flavors delivered straight to your door.

Ready to Shake Up The Best Moonshine Recipes?

Skip the store-bought candy and create a moment that shines. Whether you prefer the bite of a classic spirit or the smooth finish of cream moonshine, these recipes are the perfect way to toast to love.

So go ahead, grab your favorite jar of Midnight Moon, choose a recipe, and shake up some memories with the one you love. Cheers to a Valentine’s Day filled with sweet sips and even sweeter moments. 

Did you try one of these recipes? Snap a photo of your Valentine’s spread and tag us @midnightmoonusa on Instagram or TikTok! We love seeing how you shake up the holidays.